Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Is Mohammad (Peace be upon Him) Alive?

This is going to be a very controversial post and I'm going to generate a huge bunch of haters this time...

So, that's what they say... That RasooluLLAH (peace be upon Him) is alive.

So, there are a few things I want to ask them.

1. If He's (Peace be upon Him) alive, then are you saying that he wasn't a human? Because every human dies one day (death isn't the end of course, it's just a change of place of life).

2. Ok Ok! I got you, He's alive, but that means my grandfather who died a few years ago is alive too... isn't it??
Ok then that means RasoolULLAH (peace be upon Him) isn't alive in this world either... because as RasooluLLAH said himself that:
I'm a human like you

3. Ok, You mean to say that RasoolULLAH (Peace be upon him) is alive while ALLAH says in Qur'an:
Every living being will taste death

So, aren't you negating Qur'an when you say so?

4. Let me ask you just the last question this time, if you say that RasooluLLAH (Peace be upon him) is alive and never died then.
RasoolULLAH Mohammad (Peace be upon him) said himself,
"No prophet after me"

So, He (Peace be upon Him) said, "No prophets after me" this means current time is his time and not the time after his so that means there can be prophets today isn't it??? Aren't you paving a way for Qadyanis and other false prophets??

I really feel sad when someone start this conversation that RasoolULLAH Mohammad (Peace be upon Him) is alive and I negate him.

Actually there is no end of a Human's life. It ends here and starts there. That's what happens to everybody that is what happened to Him (RasooluLLAH (Peace be upon Him)). But if someone say that no, He (Peace be upon Him) is alive exclusively and no-one else is, then he/she should answer my questions first.


Umm Omar said...

Assalamu alaikum brother,

Just curious-who claims this? I don't take the time to learn much about the deviant sects of Islam, as I already have much to learn about the path I'm on!

Aurangzeb said...

There is a group in Sunnis called Brailvis.

There are 3 main sects:
1. Sunni
2. Shia
3. Ahl-e-Hadith (people also remember them as Salafis or Wahabis but these are conventional names)

Sunnis are further divided into two main groups
1. Brailvis
2. Devbandis

Devbandis are named after University of Devband (Devband is in India) which was a well-known Islamic Research Center of the subcontinent (when Pakistan and India were not separated it was called subcontinent). Devbandis are more authentic to other groups of Muslims. Ahl-e-Hadith refuse to say prayers after Sunni-Brailvis or Shias but they happily say their prayers after Sunni-Devbandis.

Brailvis are followers of Some Ahmad Brailvi (I don't know the exact name) who was named Brailvi after his city named Brailya. said...

I've met a lot of people who want to believe that he (saw) is still alive. The main reason why they feel its okay to ask him for help when going to his grave.

Aurangzeb said...

A few ignorant people do this (asking Mohammad (Peace be upon Him) for help. But this is mostly due to ignorance and not a fault in the sect. And the people of Ahl-e-Hadith (ordinary people) hate these people due to ignorance too.

To be exact, the main reason they say RasooluLLAH (Peace be upon Him) is alive is that everybody is alive here or there. Death is just a change of place. So, in this sense they are true actually. Mohammad (Peace be upon Him) is alive ofcourse. So, Ahl-e-Hadith people who call them ignorant or Mushrik are ignorant themselves and just creating a hatred among people

Samimaneh said...

Assalamu Alaykum,
you have mentioned a good point , that muhammad SAS is not alive!
We commemorate the Wafat(death) of the prophet pBUH on 28th of safar (hijri qamari)....
but I see nothing wrong with tawassul ...which is mentioned in quran too

by the way Eid Mab3ath (27th of rajab) mubarak to all muslims